August 14, 2019

Poorest Rwandans Refused Passports – Claims New Research


Trustworthy and indepth news stories are more important now than ever.
Support our newsroom by MAKING A CONTRIBUTION HERE
A village meeting in rural Rwanda. The research claims local officials are hiding information about people from central government planners

Anti-graft group Transparency Rwanda has claimed in new research that derogatory names are being used on poorest Rwandans including that they are ‘imfungwa za leta’ or “government’s prisoners”.

The findings are contained in a research report on the Ubudehe social economic categorisations.

All Rwandans belong to one of four categories. The poorest and most vulnerable Rwandans are placed in Category 1 and 2, while relatively OK are in 3rd, as the wealthy are in the fourth category. These categories were introduced following the 2012 national census.

Currently, according to government figures, 52.4% of Rwandans are in Category 3, as 33.4% in Category 2, while 0.3% are Category 4 (wealthy).

At least 11.5% are in Category 1, whereas 1.5% do not belong in any category.

Those in category 1 are considered so poor they cannot even afford food and all the basics. They get completely free treatment in hospitals, and require less marks to qualify for university.

But as they benefit from all the freebies, according to the Transparency International partner, the government has stripped them of some of their rights.
The local government ministry has since early this year been undertaking a review of the Ubudehe program in response to fierce criticism from all corners.

A woman in Rubavu district is quoted by Transparency as saying that she had got a job outside Rwanda but could not get a passport from the Immigration and Emigration Directorate.

Another woman in Kayonza district had gotten a ‘muzungu’ (white) hubby who was preparing to take her out of Rwanda to live with him. She did not travel as she could not get a passport.

There is no known law or government policy barring poor people from passports, but these Transparency revelations are going to cause a national storm.

Already, at the event today where the Transparency Rwanda research was being unveiled, a government minister dismissed the allegations as impossible.

“I don’t know about these allegations that people are being denied travel documents, actually the authors of the research should give us identities of those affected and the officials refused,” said Dr Alvera Mukabaramba, the state minister in charge of social affairs, in the local government ministry.

The study, based on 2,400 respondents from across the country, also reports that only 50.6% were comfortable with the Ubudehe category in which they are based.

Ingabire Marie Immacule, the head of Transparency Rwanda, accused local officials of “hiding” information about the conditions of their people to get better performance rankings.

“They fabricate numbers create inexistent beings which they give to [government] to show that all people in their locality have been uplifted from poverty,” she said.

At least 40% said they had been denied a service yet they were supposed to get it.

We can't do quality journalism without your support

Perhaps it goes without saying — but producing quality journalism isn't cheap. At a time when newsroom resources and revenue are declining, The Chronicles remains committed to "Serving Your Right To Know The Truth". Stand with us as we document Rwanda's remarkable journey for you and the future generation. Do you value our journalism? We can't do it without you. Show us with your support by CONTRIBUTING HERE.
Email your news TIPS to info@chronicles.rw or WhatsApp +250788351327.
You can also find us on Signal

42 Comments

  1. Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    The text in your article seem to be running off the screen in Opera.

    I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I
    thought I’d post to let you know. The design look great though!
    Hope you get the issue fixed soon. Thanks

  2. I know this website gives quality depending posts and extra material,
    is there any other site which presents such data in quality?

  3. I am often seeking for new facts on this essential
    subject matter, and am specifically ecstatic
    the moment I find blogs which might be well-written and well-researched.

    Thanks for featuring this remarkable data, and i
    also search ahead to reading more right from your weblog in the foreseeable future.

  4. This is not the first instance I came upon a weblog that
    was truly worth commenting on. This unique document is
    stimulating to me. I in reality , live a daily life of a good number of modes; that is to say that my
    work activities range the gamut. I carry out Perinatal Massage.
    Furthermore, I buy and sell collectibles. I’m mastering Linux.

    And, that’s basically a few pursuits I carry out. Anyhow, my point is,
    each one of us considers a subject matter from a exclusive perception. Just about every single encounter we have forms us and each of our perspective of our own selves and the society all
    around us. I believe that identifying some larger view of reality
    is just where every little thing all of us converse about leads to.

    That being said, exactly how can people young and old in that case correspond?
    Is it actually possible? I believe each of our unique contributions to the Web Commons changes a large number of people, most likely.
    Therefore consider that, blog creators and commenters.
    Your current feedback could guide some other individual. Or even, comments can certainly achieve the opposite.
    And, you really should preferably care to try to assist other people
    to blossom and never decline. Thanks a lot for this unique blog site; I actually am filing this blog along with my additional exceptional weblogs I’ve come across that I
    sometimes troubled to comment on. Continue to never stop
    crafting! Continue to keep articulating!

  5. Mankind can easily pretty much all reap the benefits of finding out more regarding themselves and our overall health and well being.
    Specified activities and amounts may contain great profit to all of us, and
    we all ought to master more information about them. Your blog seems
    to have provided a beneficial point of view which is to be helpful to various groups and individuals,
    and I love your posting your emotions this way.

  6. I am really usually endeavouring to remain up to date on the current clinical resources with respect to maternity, seeing that my own purpose in everyday life is just as a Pregnancy
    Massage specialist. With regard to assisting this unique adult
    population, I find that there does exist almost nothing which
    in turn any individual pair of women share away from the proven fact that they will be mothers-to-be.
    On the other hand, Pregnancy Massage, prenatal yoga exercises,
    in addition to employing a labor and birth doula are actually tips that will be pretty much widely germane to
    get the best possible childbirth experience.

  7. Hi, I do think this is an excellent site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I may come back once again since I bookmarked it. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide other people.

  8. Any time I’m scrutinizing the web, on occasion I like to scan content I discover.
    Generally, I’ll find new guidance, or perhaps
    a innovative method of looking into problems that
    I hadn’t known about before. When this occurs, I am consistently appreciative.
    Given that I might not have an opportunity to use the
    web much, attributable to my work as an at home massage therapist, I aim to take benefit from my activities on the web.

  9. The following blog site is pleasurable. Articles like this
    are sometimes avoided, if perhaps fact be told. Commonly the highest quality of the
    Web isn’t actually the most broadly touted article
    content, but instead almost everything other than them, the forgotten about masses with
    personal blogs that are ultimately much more desirable rather than those of critical widley known people today.
    Now this is such a blog website. I will give useful information, possibly even in cases where we’re not prompted to do so.

    First is, continue creating. Secondary is, always keep composing on the regular basis.
    Third is, use your blog website to improve your own approach.
    I am absolutely not a article writer per se; I am in fact a Postnatal
    Massage Therapist. I perform Postnatal Massage Therapy, supporting females to recover following having a
    little one. It’s enjoyable work. That is precisely what I use
    a lot of of my hours accomplishing, yet I have as well loved producing from
    the time frame I was younger. I am a well-read person and just about every year I read a heap far higher
    compared with me personally. haha In the following four seasons,
    maybe I will get serious related to running a blog.

    The problem is, it can not basically an outline; the efforts of
    crafting and writing often makes a weblog mature in time.

  10. magnificent publish, very informative. I’m wondering why the other specialists of this sector do not notice this.

    You should continue your writing. I am confident, you’ve a
    huge readers’ base already!

  11. I have been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or weblog posts on this
    kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this site.
    Reading this information So i am satisfied to convey that I
    have an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed.
    I so much indubitably will make certain to don?t disregard
    this web site and provides it a look on a continuing basis.

  12. Whilst I am reading the internet, usually I like to check out content articles I
    come across. On many occasions, I can uncover brand new facts, or
    perhaps a innovative new style of contemplating things
    that I hadn’t contemplated previously. In such a situation, I’m generally grateful.
    On the grounds that I haven’t got a chance to use the internet so much, caused by my job as an at home massage therapist, I try to
    maximize my activities on the net.

  13. I actually oftentimes encounter web sites like this at
    the most unexpected instances. Like at present, I was researching a specific thing on an altogether different area and I stumbled upon this web site in its place.
    I sometimes appreciate searching online for posts, but
    typically I like to be outside the house, backpacking in the neighborhood woodlands.

    You’ll find nothing is like fresh air to cause you to really feel re-energized.
    That is while i am not working as an in home massages therapist.

    That takes up the vast majority of my time.

  14. I typically stumble upon sites like this at some of the most improbable occasions.

    For instance currently, I had been trying to find something on an altogether different subject
    and I uncovered this article in fact. I commonly like examining
    the world wide web for articles or blog posts, but yet principally I want to
    be out of doors, camping in the local woods.
    Few things are similar to outdoors to cause you to really feel revitalized.

    This can be while i am not accomplishing work as an at home massage therapist.
    That takes up nearly all of my own energy.

  15. I actually typically come across sites such as this at some of the most unexpected times.
    For instance right now, I had been seeking something on an altogether different subject and I located this website instead.
    I sometimes like surfing the world wide web for posts,
    but yet usually I love to be out in the open, camping in the area forest land.
    There is nothing like clean air to make you truly feel revitalized.
    That is next time i am not functioning as an in home massages therapist.
    That uses up virtually all of my precious time.

  16. I have a tendency to come across weblogs like this at the most impossible occasions.
    Such as presently, I was searching for a specific thing on an altogether different area and I stumbled upon this web site instead.
    I more often than not appreciate searching cyberspace for articles or
    blog posts, on the other hand for the most part I like
    to be out in the open, hiking in the local woodlands. Absolutely nothing is like fresh air to
    make you truly feel invigorated. That is as soon as i am not earning a living as an in-home massage
    therapist. It uses up much of my personal precious time.

  17. What’s up everybody, here every person is sharing
    these kinds of experience, so it’s fastidious to read this weblog, and I used to pay a quick visit this weblog all the time.

  18. Its such as you read my thoughts! You seem to grasp so much approximately this,
    such as you wrote the book in it or something. I feel that you just can do
    with a few % to power the message house a little bit, however instead
    of that, this is excellent blog. A fantastic read. I’ll definitely be back.

  19. I have been surfing on-line greater than three hours as of late, yet I never found
    any attention-grabbing article like yours. It’s beautiful worth enough for me.
    In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made excellent content
    as you did, the net might be a lot more helpful
    than ever before.

  20. This is absolutely not the first moment in time I unearthed a blog that was definitely worth commenting on. This distinct write-up is significant to me
    personally. I in reality live a way of life of a variety of ways; that is to say
    that my employment routines are distinct. I carry out Postpartum Massage.

    On top of that, I trade in collectibles. I’m learning Centos8.
    And, that’s basically a few pursuits I carry out. In any
    case, my point is, each one of us approaches a niche
    from a exclusive viewpoint. Virtually every experience we
    have shapes us and each of our viewpoint of ourselves and
    the globe around us all. I believe that seeking out
    some more significant awareness of real truth is just where all the things many of us communicate about brings us to.
    So, how do men or women then relate? Is it even possible?
    I think that all of our individual additions to the Internet
    Commons alters a good number of men and women, sometimes. And
    so contemplate that, bloggers and commenters. Your comment can potentially help out someone else.
    Or even, comments can certainly do the complete opposite.
    Plus, you actually need to care to try to benefit
    other individuals to grow and never suffer. Bless you for this unique blog; I actually am logging this post with
    my various other incredibly good blogs I’ve discovered that I sometimes bothered to comment on. Continue
    to never stop penning! Continue to keep articulating!

  21. I actually frequently encounter internet sites like this at some of the most unlikely moments.
    Similar to presently, I was on the search for something on an altogether different area and I found
    this web site in fact. I many times spend time browsing the internet for content, on the other
    hand typically I wish to be outdoors, hiking in the regional
    forest land. There is nothing like fresh air to cause you
    to feel energized. This can be when I am not doing work as an in home massages therapist.
    That occupies much of my time.

  22. I have a tendency to encounter web sites similar to
    this at the most unlikely instances. For instance right now,
    I had been researching something on an altogether different topic and
    I encountered this article instead. I quite often appreciate examining the internet for
    articles, but more often than not I prefer to be outdoors, experiencing the outdoors in the regional woodlands.
    There is nothing like outdoors to make you feel energized.
    This is whenever i am not being employed as
    an at home massage therapist. It consumes a majority of my own precious time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *