April 6, 2020

Can Liberal Democracy Survive COVID-19?

Ana Palacio April 6, 2020

Trustworthy and indepth news stories are more important now than ever.
Support our newsroom by MAKING A CONTRIBUTION HERE

Even if Western leaders manage to limit the COVID-19 outbreak’s immediate fallout, it will mean little without forward-looking efforts to strengthen liberal-democratic systems from within. Such a failure would could well amount to handing China victory in the global contest of ideas that is now underway.

VENICE, ITALY – MARCH 9: A completely empty San Marco Square is seen on March 9, 2020 in Venice, Italy. Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte announced a “national emergency” due to the coronavirus outbreak and imposed quarantines on the Lombardy and Veneto regions, which contain roughly a quarter of the country’s population. Italy has the highest number of cases and fatalities in Europe. The movements in and out are allowed only for work reasons, health reasons proven by a medical certificate.The justifications for the movements needs to be certified with a self-declaration by filling in forms provided by the police forces in charge of the checks. (Photo by Marco Di Lauro/Getty Images)

MADRID – By some mix of cruel irony and remarkable prescience, the theme of last year’s Venice Biennale – the biennial art exhibition’s 58th incarnation – was: “May you live in interesting times.” The line, purportedly a translation of an old Chinese curse, was meant to highlight the precariousness of life in this dangerous and uncertain age. With the COVID-19 pandemic ravaging the world, and credible global leadership nowhere to be seen, that reality has become impossible to ignore.

Venice has always been a monument to human ingenuity. Situated in the most improbable of locations, it rose to prominence as a hub of trade and commerce, supported by the institutions that underpinned the first era of globalization. It was thus a forebear of liberal internationalism, and remains a symbol of reason, humane values, and breathtaking artistic achievement.

Today, Venice, like most of Europe, stands empty. Moreover, the values and possibilities it represents are nowhere to be seen – on the continent or beyond. Instead, the world is seemingly at the mercy of the United States and China, which appear more concerned with upholding their great-power competition than resolving the COVID-19 crisis.

This competition for global primacy, which has been escalating for years, is also a clash of models. The Chinese system privileges the social harmony that lies at the heart of Confucianism. The American – and, indeed, the Western – system emphasizes the primacy of the individual, in the tradition of the Enlightenment.

The response to the COVID-19 crisis has thrown this difference into sharp relief. In China, local authorities initially suppressed information about the virus, in order to protect the Communist Party’s reputation. When that proved untenable, the government implemented draconian lockdowns. It has since been pushing the narrative (despite dubious data) that these measures have succeeded in curbing the virus’s spread in China and are crucial to an effective response anywhere.

In the US, by contrast, the crisis has been characterized by the tension among the individual rights to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” upheld in the Declaration of Independence as stated. The pandemic threatens life, but the response needed to protect life would undermine liberty; the pursuit of happiness will take a hit either way. No crisis in recent memory has posed such an all-encompassing challenge to the pillars of Western liberalism.

life before. The specter of a nuclear exchange during the Cold War implied the possibility of casualties far in excess of even the worst predictions for the COVID-19 pandemic. But the risk was largely theoretical. And the logic of mutually assured destruction – if one side launched a nuclear attack, both sides would perish – proved to be a powerful deterrent.

In the case of COVID-19, by contrast, the risk is tangible and specific. People are contracting this virus, and people are dying alone, forced to say goodbye to their loved ones over video calls. There is no cure, let alone a vaccine, and it is so contagious that health systems are becoming overwhelmed. This has generated a simultaneous sense of urgency and helplessness to which the Cold War does not compare.

Western democracies have also curtailed liberty during previous crises. Following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, the US Patriot Act drastically expanded law enforcement’s surveillance and investigative powers. More recent terrorist violence in Europe has led to similar developments.

But, again, the threat posed by the COVID-19 crisis is far more immediate and palpable. Surreptitious wiretapping is one thing; restricted freedom of movement is quite another. So far, lockdowns, quarantines, and border controls have been broadly accepted as necessary, but the longer they endure, the more they will erode the foundations of free, liberal societies.

Thomas Jefferson’s appealing but amorphous idea of the pursuit of happiness is particularly vulnerable. In recent decades, as unbridled capitalism has seized the public consciousness, happiness has come to be equated with economic security and prosperity. It is a shallow metric, but how contentment is measured in gross terms today will define the crisis response.

That response is causing economies to a grind to a halt. In the US, 6.6 million people applied for unemployment benefits last week, after the longstanding record of 695,000, set in 1982, was overwhelmed by the 3.3 million claims the previous week. As the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis in Europe showed, mass unemployment and belt-tightening can be highly disruptive, as they fuel mistrust of existing institutions.

Together with threats to life and limits on liberty, the coming economic crisis will deepen doubts about Western liberalism and weaken its position in the global contest of ideas that is currently underway. It is thus imperative that Western leaders not only limit the spread of COVID-19, but also foster social cohesion, devise a credible path back toward growth and normalcy, and reinvigorate the values and institutions that underpin liberal democratic societies. To succeed, they will need to revive the ethos that citizenship entails both duties and rights. The scenes of heroism by medical professionals, service workers, and community members that the pandemic has produced should help to advance this objective.

Even if Western leaders manage to limit the COVID-19 outbreak’s short-term fallout, it will mean little without forward-looking efforts to strengthen liberal-democratic systems from within. Such a failure would leave the West vulnerable to a China that, accurately or not, is presenting its model as the best solution to the challenges of these interesting times.

Ana Palacio is former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Spain and former Senior Vice President and General Counsel of the World Bank Group. She is a visiting lecturer at Georgetown University.

The text has been adapted from Project Syndicate website

We can't do quality journalism without your support

Perhaps it goes without saying — but producing quality journalism isn't cheap. At a time when newsroom resources and revenue are declining, The Chronicles remains committed to "Serving Your Right To Know The Truth". Stand with us as we document Rwanda's remarkable journey for you and the future generation. Do you value our journalism? We can't do it without you. Show us with your support by CONTRIBUTING HERE.
Email your news TIPS to info@chronicles.rw or WhatsApp +250788351327.
You can also find us on Signal

June 26, 2024
0 0

UBUDASA: Kagame and the Inkotanyi Magic

Opinions
April 27, 2023
3,706 0

Unlocking Africa’s Potential: The Urgent Need for Digital Transformation

Opinions
March 24, 2023
1,286 0

Localizing Development Research

Opinions
March 24, 2023
1,368 0

Artificial Idiocy

1,027 Comments

  1. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board
    and I find It really useful & it helped me out much.
    I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

    Reply

  2. OMG! This is amazing. Ireally appreciate
    it~ May I with heart reach out a secret only I KNOW and if you want
    to really findout? You really have to believe mme
    and have faith and I will show how to make passive income Once again I
    want to show my appreciation and may all the blessing goes to you now!.

    Reply

  3. I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.
    The sketch is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get bought an edginess over that you wish
    be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since exactly the same nearly a
    lot often inside case you shield this increase.

    Reply

  4. Howdy! This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog.
    Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but
    I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to begin. Do you have any ideas or suggestions?

    Many thanks

    Reply

  5. I blog often and I really appreciate your content.

    The article has truly peaked my interest. I’m
    going to take a note of your website and keep checking for new information about
    once a week. I subscribed to your RSS feed as well.

    Reply

  6. Hello there, I found your web site by means of Google
    even as searching for a related subject, your site got here up, it seems
    good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    Hi there, simply become alert to your blog via Google,
    and located that it’s truly informative. I am gonna be careful for brussels.
    I’ll be grateful in the event you proceed this in future.

    Many people can be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

    Reply

  7. Hello, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some
    overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, wonderful blog!

    Reply

  10. The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesn’t fail me just as much as this particular one. After all, Yes, it was my choice to read through, nonetheless I truly thought you would have something interesting to talk about. All I hear is a bunch of crying about something you could possibly fix if you weren’t too busy looking for attention.

    Reply

  14. Hello, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam remarks? If so how do you protect against it, any plugin or anything you can recommend? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any support is very much appreciated.

    Reply

  21. I don’t even understand how I ended up here, but
    I assumed this publish was great. I do not realize who you’re but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you happen to aren’t already.
    Cheers!

    Reply

  23. I’m very pleased to discover this page. I want to to thank you for your time for this particularly
    fantastic read!! I definitely savored every bit of it and I
    have you saved to fav to look at new information in your web
    site.

    Reply

  24. Hello there, I think your website might be having browser compatibility
    issues. When I take a look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine however when opening in Internet Explorer, it’s
    got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Aside from that, fantastic website!

    Reply

  30. Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely
    long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I had written and say,
    I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new
    to everything. Do you have any points for novice blog writers?
    I’d definitely appreciate it.

    Reply

  32. Great beat ! I wish to apprentice whilst you amend your site, how can i subscribe for a blog web site?

    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I were a little bit acquainted
    of this your broadcast offered brilliant
    clear idea

    Reply

  40. Having read this I believed it was extremely enlightening. I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this article together. I once again find myself spending a lot of time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worthwhile!

    Reply

  375. Boostaro increases blood flow to the reproductive organs, leading to stronger and more vibrant erections. It provides a powerful boost that can make you feel like you’ve unlocked the secret to firm erections

    Reply

  376. Sight Care is a daily supplement proven in clinical trials and conclusive science to improve vision by nourishing the body from within. The Sight Care formula claims to reverse issues in eyesight, and every ingredient is completely natural.

    Reply

  377. Sight Care is a daily supplement proven in clinical trials and conclusive science to improve vision by nourishing the body from within. The Sight Care formula claims to reverse issues in eyesight, and every ingredient is completely natural.

    Reply

  379. Dentitox Pro is a liquid dietary solution created as a serum to support healthy gums and teeth. Dentitox Pro formula is made in the best natural way with unique, powerful botanical ingredients that can support healthy teeth.

    Reply

  380. FitSpresso stands out as a remarkable dietary supplement designed to facilitate effective weight loss. Its unique blend incorporates a selection of natural elements including green tea extract, milk thistle, and other components with presumed weight loss benefits.

    Reply

  381. Gorilla Flow is a non-toxic supplement that was developed by experts to boost prostate health for men. It’s a blend of all-natural nutrients, including Pumpkin Seed Extract Stinging Nettle Extract, Gorilla Cherry and Saw Palmetto, Boron, and Lycopene.

    Reply

  382. BioFit is an all-natural supplement that is known to enhance and balance good bacteria in the gut area. To lose weight, you need to have a balanced hormones and body processes. Many times, people struggle with weight loss because their gut health has issues.

    Reply

  384. Kerassentials are natural skin care products with ingredients such as vitamins and plants that help support good health and prevent the appearance of aging skin. They’re also 100% natural and safe to use. The manufacturer states that the product has no negative side effects and is safe to take on a daily basis.

    Reply

  385. GlucoBerry is one of the biggest all-natural dietary and biggest scientific breakthrough formulas ever in the health industry today. This is all because of its amazing high-quality cutting-edge formula that helps treat high blood sugar levels very naturally and effectively.

    Reply

  387. TerraCalm is an antifungal mineral clay that may support the health of your toenails. It is for those who struggle with brittle, weak, and discoloured nails. It has a unique blend of natural ingredients that may work to nourish and strengthen your toenails.

    Reply

  388. Sight Care is a daily supplement proven in clinical trials and conclusive science to improve vision by nourishing the body from within. The SightCare formula claims to reverse issues in eyesight, and every ingredient is completely natural.

    Reply

  389. SightCare clears out inflammation and nourishes the eye and brain cells, improving communication between both organs. Consequently, you should expect to see results in as little as six months if you combine this with other healthy habits.

    Reply

  390. EyeFortin is a natural vision support formula crafted with a blend of plant-based compounds and essential minerals. It aims to enhance vision clarity, focus, and moisture balance.

    Reply

  391. Amiclear is a dietary supplement designed to support healthy blood sugar levels and assist with glucose metabolism. It contains eight proprietary blends of ingredients that have been clinically proven to be effective.

    Reply

  392. Neotonics is an essential probiotic supplement that works to support the microbiome in the gut and also works as an anti-aging formula. The formula targets the cause of the aging of the skin.

    Reply

  393. HoneyBurn is a 100% natural honey mixture formula that can support both your digestive health and fat-burning mechanism. Since it is formulated using 11 natural plant ingredients, it is clinically proven to be safe and free of toxins, chemicals, or additives.

    Reply

  394. Neurodrine is a fantastic dietary supplement that protects your mind and improves memory performance. It can help you improve your focus and concentration.

    Reply

  395. TropiSlim is a unique dietary supplement designed to address specific health concerns, primarily focusing on weight management and related issues in women, particularly those over the age of 40.

    Reply

  396. Introducing FlowForce Max, a solution designed with a single purpose: to provide men with an affordable and safe way to address BPH and other prostate concerns. Unlike many costly supplements or those with risky stimulants, we’ve crafted FlowForce Max with your well-being in mind. Don’t compromise your health or budget – choose FlowForce Max for effective prostate support today!

    Reply

  398. Glucofort Blood Sugar Support is an all-natural dietary formula that works to support healthy blood sugar levels. It also supports glucose metabolism. According to the manufacturer, this supplement can help users keep their blood sugar levels healthy and within a normal range with herbs, vitamins, plant extracts, and other natural ingredients.

    Reply

  399. Puravive introduced an innovative approach to weight loss and management that set it apart from other supplements. It enhances the production and storage of brown fat in the body, a stark contrast to the unhealthy white fat that contributes to obesity.

    Reply

  400. Erec Prime is a cutting-edge male enhancement formula with high quality raw ingredients designed to enhance erection quality and duration, providing increased stamina and a heightened libido.

    Reply

  402. Metabo Flex is a nutritional formula that enhances metabolic flexibility by awakening the calorie-burning switch in the body. The supplement is designed to target the underlying causes of stubborn weight gain utilizing a special “miracle plant” from Cambodia that can melt fat 24/7.

    Reply

  403. Prostadine is a dietary supplement meticulously formulated to support prostate health, enhance bladder function, and promote overall urinary system well-being. Crafted from a blend of entirely natural ingredients, Prostadine draws upon a recent groundbreaking discovery by Harvard scientists.

    Reply

  404. t’s Time To Say Goodbye To All Your Bedroom Troubles And Enjoy The Ultimate Satisfaction And Give Her The Leg-shaking Orgasms. The Endopeak Is Your True Partner To Build Those Monster Powers In Your Manhood You Ever Craved For..

    Reply

  405. With its all-natural ingredients and impressive results, Aizen Power supplement is quickly becoming a popular choice for anyone looking for an effective solution for improve sexual health with this revolutionary treatment.

    Reply

  406. The Quietum Plus supplement promotes healthy ears, enables clearer hearing, and combats tinnitus by utilizing only the purest natural ingredients. Supplements are widely used for various reasons, including boosting energy, lowering blood pressure, and boosting metabolism.

    Reply

  408. Nervogen Pro, A Cutting-Edge Supplement Dedicated To Enhancing Nerve Health And Providing Natural Relief From Discomfort. Our Mission Is To Empower You To Lead A Life Free From The Limitations Of Nerve-Related Challenges. With A Focus On Premium Ingredients And Scientific Expertise.

    Reply

  409. Claritox Pro™ is a natural dietary supplement that is formulated to support brain health and promote a healthy balance system to prevent dizziness, risk injuries, and disability. This formulation is made using naturally sourced and effective ingredients that are mixed in the right way and in the right amounts to deliver effective results.

    Reply

  410. InchaGrow is an advanced male enhancement supplement. Discover the natural way to boost your sexual health. Increase desire, improve erections, and experience more intense orgasms.

    Reply

  415. Leanotox is one of the world’s most unique products designed to promote optimal weight and balance blood sugar levels while curbing your appetite,detoxifying and boosting metabolism.

    Reply

  417. Illuderma is a groundbreaking skincare serum with a unique formulation that sets itself apart in the realm of beauty and skin health. What makes this serum distinct is its composition of 16 powerful natural ingredients.

    Reply

  419. DentaTonic™ is formulated to support lactoperoxidase levels in saliva, which is important for maintaining oral health. This enzyme is associated with defending teeth and gums from bacteria that could lead to dental issues.

    Reply

  420. Keratone is 100% natural formula, non invasive, and helps remove fungal build-up in your toe, improve circulation in capillaries so you can easily and effortlessly break free from toenail fungus.

    Reply

  421. LeanBliss™ is a natural weight loss supplement that has gained immense popularity due to its safe and innovative approach towards weight loss and support for healthy blood sugar.

    Reply

  422. By taking two capsules of Abdomax daily, you can purportedly relieve gut health problems more effectively than any diet or medication. The supplement also claims to lower blood sugar, lower blood pressure, and provide other targeted health benefits.

    Reply

  423. BioVanish a weight management solution that’s transforming the approach to healthy living. In a world where weight loss often feels like an uphill battle, BioVanish offers a refreshing and effective alternative. This innovative supplement harnesses the power of natural ingredients to support optimal weight management.

    Reply

  424. Fast Lean Pro is a natural dietary aid designed to boost weight loss. Fast Lean Pro powder supplement claims to harness the benefits of intermittent fasting, promoting cellular renewal and healthy metabolism.

    Reply

  427. Embrace the power of Red Boost™ and unlock a renewed sense of vitality and confidence in your intimate experiences. effects. It is produced under the most strict and precise conditions.

    Reply

  428. Zoracel is an extraordinary oral care product designed to promote healthy teeth and gums, provide long-lasting fresh breath, support immune health, and care for the ear, nose, and throat.

    Reply

  430. LeanBiome is designed to support healthy weight loss. Formulated through the latest Ivy League research and backed by real-world results, it’s your partner on the path to a healthier you.

    Reply

  431. Sight Care is a daily supplement proven in clinical trials and conclusive science to improve vision by nourishing the body from within. The SightCare formula claims to reverse issues in eyesight, and every ingredient is completely natural.

    Reply

  440. Puravive introduced an innovative approach to weight loss and management that set it apart from other supplements. It enhances the production and storage of brown fat in the body, a stark contrast to the unhealthy white fat that contributes to obesity. https://puravivebuynow.us/

    Reply

  446. BioFit is an all-natural supplement that is known to enhance and balance good bacteria in the gut area. To lose weight, you need to have a balanced hormones and body processes. Many times, people struggle with weight loss because their gut health has issues. https://biofitbuynow.us/

    Reply

  447. Prostadine is a dietary supplement meticulously formulated to support prostate health, enhance bladder function, and promote overall urinary system well-being. Crafted from a blend of entirely natural ingredients, Prostadine draws upon a recent groundbreaking discovery by Harvard scientists. This discovery identified toxic minerals present in hard water as a key contributor to prostate issues. https://prostadinebuynow.us/

    Reply

  448. Kerassentials are natural skin care products with ingredients such as vitamins and plants that help support good health and prevent the appearance of aging skin. They’re also 100% natural and safe to use. The manufacturer states that the product has no negative side effects and is safe to take on a daily basis. Kerassentials is a convenient, easy-to-use formula. https://kerassentialsbuynow.us/

    Reply

  449. GlucoBerry is one of the biggest all-natural dietary and biggest scientific breakthrough formulas ever in the health industry today. This is all because of its amazing high-quality cutting-edge formula that helps treat high blood sugar levels very naturally and effectively. https://glucoberrybuynow.us/

    Reply

  453. FitSpresso stands out as a remarkable dietary supplement designed to facilitate effective weight loss. Its unique blend incorporates a selection of natural elements including green tea extract, milk thistle, and other components with presumed weight loss benefits. https://fitspressobuynow.us/

    Reply

  454. Endo Pump Male Enhancement works by increasing blood flow to the penis, which assist to achieve and maintain erections. This formula includes nitric oxide, a powerful vasodilator that widens blood vessels and improves circulation. Other key ingredients https://endopumpbuynow.us/

    Reply

  465. Claritox Pro™ is a natural dietary supplement that is formulated to support brain health and promote a healthy balance system to prevent dizziness, risk injuries, and disability. This formulation is made using naturally sourced and effective ingredients that are mixed in the right way and in the right amounts to deliver effective results. https://claritoxprobuynow.us/

    Reply

  468. Metabo Flex is a nutritional formula that enhances metabolic flexibility by awakening the calorie-burning switch in the body. The supplement is designed to target the underlying causes of stubborn weight gain utilizing a special “miracle plant” from Cambodia that can melt fat 24/7. https://metaboflexbuynow.us/

    Reply

  470. Cortexi is a completely natural product that promotes healthy hearing, improves memory, and sharpens mental clarity. Cortexi hearing support formula is a combination of high-quality natural components that work together to offer you with a variety of health advantages, particularly for persons in their middle and late years. https://cortexibuynow.us/

    Reply

  475. Gut Vita™ is a daily supplement that helps consumers to improve the balance in their gut microbiome, which supports the health of their immune system. It supports healthy digestion, even for consumers who have maintained an unhealthy diet for a long time. https://gutvitabuynow.us/

    Reply

  478. Illuderma is a serum designed to deeply nourish, clear, and hydrate the skin. The goal of this solution began with dark spots, which were previously thought to be a natural symptom of ageing. The creators of Illuderma were certain that blue modern radiation is the source of dark spots after conducting extensive research. https://illudermabuynow.us/

    Reply

  486. Red Boost is a male-specific natural dietary supplement. Nitric oxide is naturally increased by it, which enhances blood circulation all throughout the body. This may improve your general well-being. Red Boost is an excellent option if you’re trying to assist your circulatory system. https://redboostbuynow.us/

    Reply

  488. BioVanish a weight management solution that’s transforming the approach to healthy living. In a world where weight loss often feels like an uphill battle, BioVanish offers a refreshing and effective alternative. This innovative supplement harnesses the power of natural ingredients to support optimal weight management. https://biovanishbuynow.us/

    Reply

  500. May I simply just say what a relief to uncover someone that really understands what they’re talking about online. You certainly understand how to bring an issue to light and make it important. A lot more people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I can’t believe you’re not more popular given that you surely have the gift.

    Reply

  510. You are so interesting! I do not suppose I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find somebody with a few original thoughts on this topic. Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This site is one thing that is required on the internet, someone with a little originality.

    Reply

  516. Hello! This post could not be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my good old room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this page to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

  518. Cortexi is a completely natural product that promotes healthy hearing, improves memory, and sharpens mental clarity. Cortexi hearing support formula is a combination of high-quality natural components that work together to offer you with a variety of health advantages, particularly for persons in their middle and late years. https://cortexibuynow.us/

    Reply

  519. Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thank you so much, However I am having troubles with your RSS. I don’t understand why I cannot subscribe to it. Is there anybody else getting the same RSS problems? Anyone that knows the answer can you kindly respond? Thanks!

    Reply

  527. Unlock the incredible potential of Puravive! Supercharge your metabolism and incinerate calories like never before with our unique fusion of 8 exotic components. Bid farewell to those stubborn pounds and welcome a reinvigorated metabolism and boundless vitality. Grab your bottle today and seize this golden opportunity! https://puravivebuynow.us/

    Reply

  528. Hello, I do think your website could be having browser compatibility problems. Whenever I take a look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in IE, it’s got some overlapping issues. I just wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Besides that, excellent blog!

    Reply

  531. ProstateFlux is a dietary supplement specifically designed to promote and maintain a healthy prostate. It is formulated with a blend of natural ingredients known for their potential benefits for prostate health.